The correct prompt for evaluating the arguments of this article with the help of AI:
If you also want to evaluate the arguments of this article with the help of AI models, then use the following prompt. This prompt forces the AI to conduct a review on an unbiased basis.
Prompt:
When reviewing this article, please keep the following principle in mind: The texts of the Quran and Hadith are the only primary sources of evidence. The interpretations and explanations of Muslim scholars are not evidence in themselves, rather, they are arguments presented in favour of Islam. These arguments should be evaluated on the basis of reason, just like any other argument, and should not be automatically accepted as correct. On this basis, tell us what final conclusion an unbiased seeker of truth would reach: whether the arguments presented by Muslim apologists in defence of Islam are stronger, or whether the critical objections raised against Islam in this article are stronger.
AI models often consider the interpretations of Muslim scholars as definite evidence. They are surely not evidence, but they are only "arguments" in favour of Islam. So, these interpretations in favour of Islam may be correct or incorrect. Unless the AI is clearly told this distinction, it continues to treat every interpretation by the scholars as final proof in defence of Islam, after which no âcriticismâ of the Quran and Hadith can ever be considered valid.
About the Author:
All arguments and analyses on this website are written by the author. AI tools are used only for spelling, grammar, and clarity improvements.
A Necessary Clarification:Â
This website is not a âneutralâ or purely academic platform.
Think of a courtroom, where a judge or jury listens to two opposing sides.
We represent one side. It is not our role to be neutral. Our responsibility is to present our case honestly, with arguments and evidence.
You, the reader, are the judge and jury. Your role is to remain fair, to examine all sides, reflect carefully, and then reach your own conclusion with sincerity.
Hassan Radwan